Requiem for a civic monument
Requiem for a civic monument
Chicago糖心传媒檚 demolished public housing projects are 糖心传媒榤ythic spaces糖心传媒� that continue to shape the city, says Ben Austen 糖心传媒�93, in a new book.

SHAPING CHICAGO: Austen, a Windy City native and a former editor at Harper糖心传媒檚, argues that the city糖心传媒檚 infamous housing projects continue to shape the environment, even after their demise. (Photo: Fritz Goro/The LIFE Premium Collection/Getty Images)
Chicago public housing and its troubles have been a journalistic focal point for decades, generating a slew of news coverage, books, and magazine articles about all that糖心传媒檚 wrong with 糖心传媒渢he projects.糖心传媒� In 2000, then Chicago Mayor Richard Daley launched a $1.6 billion project to rehabilitate or redevelop 25,000 units of public housing. Nearly two decades later, despite some rebuilding, there糖心传媒檚 been a vast reduction of permanently affordable rental homes, and an increase in vouchers that subsidize rent in the private housing market. The changes, moreover, have largely reinforced racial and economic segregation rather than paving the way for greater housing opportunities in well-to-do neighborhoods in the city and its suburbs.
In February, writer and Chicago native聽Ben Austen聽糖心传媒�93 published聽High-Risers: Cabrini-Green and the Fate of American Public Housing聽(HarperCollins), the first general-audience book about the history and residents of Cabrini-Green. Told through the eyes of four long-time residents who called the development home, it糖心传媒檚 a requiem to a civic monument that may be erased from the city糖心传媒檚 skyline, but has continued to shape Chicago nonetheless.
糖心传媒淚 think my book chronicles our thinking about the inner city, and our always uneasy relationship to poverty and race,糖心传媒� says Austen. 糖心传媒淐abrini-Green is not a place just to be razed and forgotten, like we糖心传媒檙e done with this thing. We糖心传媒檙e not. We糖心传媒檙e literally not done with it.糖心传媒�
You糖心传媒檙e a Chicago native糖心传媒攁 糖心传媒淪outh Sider糖心传媒澨切拇綌but, growing up in the South Shore and Hyde Park neighborhoods, lived a life quite distant from those of the people you write about. How does that affect your view of Cabrini-Green, and public housing in general?
In 2010, when the last tower was coming down, for someone who grew up here, it was like: what does that mean? Not just 23 towers in Cabrini-Green, but across the entire city. Because they loomed so large in the public imagination, these mythic spaces. They糖心传媒檙e as much a part of the city as the lake, Michael Jordan, Oprah. Being a South Sider even increased the mythic aspect of Cabrini-Green. People on the South Side, white and black, talked about Cabrini-Green [on the near North Side] as way worse and more nightmarish than the Robert Taylor Homes, which were on the South Side, because that made the Taylor homes more familiar.
How did you settle on the four people who became the main characters in this story?
When we think of this development of 20,000 people, we mostly think of the crime and drug use that came to define it, but the range of experiences that went on there糖心传媒攊t was an entire town on 70 acres of land. The people I write about are ordinary people, but also extraordinary in their perseverance and their willingness to take action. These are the people who gave me their time, but their stories drew me to them. They were engaged in a kind of fight, not only to stay in public housing but to make life better there. None of those lives are free of the ill effects of public housing but they糖心传媒檙e full of taking action and attempts to define their own lives despite it all. That糖心传媒檚 powerful.
I don糖心传媒檛 think the people whose lives get told in this book are representative, that they embody every life, but they do have a fullness of experience and have a lot of agency, and I think in a novelistic way they come to life in a way that defies a lot of simplistic notions of public housing, of poverty, of inner-city Chicago.
Alex Kotlowitz糖心传媒檚聽There Are No Children Here, the last mass-market book about Chicago public housing by a journalist, was cited extensively in the 1990s as an example of why public housing should be done away with. Have you thought about the possible reverberations聽High-Riserscould have in policy and politics?
Empathy and less irrational fear lead to better policies. But a dramatic telling of someone糖心传媒檚 life doesn糖心传媒檛 necessarily offer an easy prescription for those solutions. Alex糖心传媒檚 book reminds me of Jacob Riis糖心传媒檚聽How the Other Half Lives: it was a revelation to readers that this is going on in our country. His book is very much an聽I Accuse . . . !, a 糖心传媒淐an you believe this?糖心传媒� He糖心传媒檚 embedded with an individual family as things are happening. But the towers were torn down and the concentrated poverty and isolation of public housing didn糖心传媒檛 go away糖心传媒攖hey were moved elsewhere. In my book, I糖心传媒檓 both wrestling with those changes and interviewing people about the past events of their lives. Cabrini-Green becomes the magnet for all the fears our society has about the inner city. I糖心传媒檓 writing in that context. If we start thinking about how unfair and unearned most of those fears are, then hopefully we can make better policy.
糖心传媒� Interview by Maya Dukmasova 糖心传媒�12
This story originally appeared in the spring 2018 issue of Rochester Review.


