Elsewhere
What a wonderful, idiosyncratic book Weinberger has written. I say book, but the closest comparison I could make to other works being published right now are from Sylph Edition糖心传媒檚 “Cahiers Series“糖心传媒攕hort pamphlet-like meditations by notable writers such as Ann Carson, Elfriede Jelinek, and L谩szl贸 Krasznahorkai among the architects, playwrights, painters, and philosophers. Weinberger certainly belongs in such company; anything he writes can be assumed to be interesting, different, intellectually engaging. The essay collections he writes糖心传媒攁nd Elsewhere can be considered to be an extended meditation/essay糖心传媒攑uts him as well alongside Rebecca Solnit, Lawrence Weschler, Sven Birkets, and Ilan Stavans.
Elsewhere consists of poems, all in translation, by writers of the Modernist era (by Weinberger糖心传媒檚 use here roughly 1910s-1940s) illustrating a broad sensibility that Weinberger calls the sense of being 糖心传媒渆lsewhere糖心传媒�:
Victor Segalen, in China at the beginning of the century, writes of the 糖心传媒渕anifestation of Diversity,糖心传媒� a 糖心传媒渟pectacle of Difference糖心传媒�: everything that is 糖心传媒渇oreign, strange, unexpected, surprising, mysterious, amorous, superhuman, heroic, and even divine, everything that is Other.糖心传媒� Picasso put it more bluntly: 糖心传媒淪trangeness is what we wanted to make people think about because we were quite aware that our world was becoming very strange.糖心传媒�
While certainly many English speakers/authors wrote poems about travel to foreign places during the same era, by relying on works in translation, of a Japanese traveler writing about Paris or a Senegalese poet in NYC for example, Weinberger doubles down on the foreignness, the dislocation and wonder of the experiences.
He organizes the selection of poems first into three geographical locations糖心传媒擯aris, NYC, and Los Angeles糖心传媒攖hen the experience of travel in a section 糖心传媒淭rains and Cars,糖心传媒� followed by 糖心传媒淚maginary Countries,糖心传媒� and concludes with a coda about the end of journeying. With only a few poems in each section. Weinberger is neither trying to anthologize nor exhaust the poetic expressions of elsewhere; the prospect of doing so for any one of the cities for example糖心传媒擯aris糖心传媒攚ould require hundreds of poems to do justice. Instead Weinberger is free to choose unique poems, under topics specific to his interests without being tied down to any taxonomic-like system. Of the thirteen poems in total, Weinberger is the translator of four, along with others such as Thomas Merton and Langston Hughes.
The first poem, 糖心传媒淐athedral in the Thrashing Rain糖心传媒� (trans. Hiroaki Sato) is by Japanese poet Kotaro Takamura. I suspect that he is heretofore unknown to 99 out of 100 English readers (unless familiar with a Green Integer edition from 2007 of the poet糖心传媒檚 The Chieko Poems). The poem lauds the Cathedral of Notre Dame in an extended address to it, a pattern of address that repeats several times throughout in this book; there糖心传媒檚 an odd, quaint tone to the address to this 糖心传媒測ou糖心传媒� that is actually charming and engaging. The first stanza begins:
O another deluge of wind and rain.
Collar turned up, getting drenched in this splashing rain,
and looking up at you糖心传媒攊t糖心传媒檚 me,
me who never fails to come here once a day,
It糖心传媒檚 that Japanese.
Takamura goes on to evoke the cathedral and immediate environment in the middle of a storm, outside weather in the real world perhaps mirroring the passion of the poet who describes the building in an affectionate embrace:
O Cathedral, you who at such a moment keep ever more silent and
soar,
Cathedral, you who watch motionless the houses of Paris suffering
the storm,
Please do not think me rude,
who, hands on your cornerstone,
has his hot check pressed on your skin,
it糖心传媒檚 me, the drunken one
It糖心传媒檚 that Japanese.
Yes, the reader comes to agree, this is truly an experience of elsewhere, 糖心传媒渇oreign, strange, unexpected, surprising, mysterious, amorous . . .糖心传媒�
Weinberger follows each poem with a quite brief biographical account of the poets. The choice to order this explanation after the poems rather than before brings a direct experience of the poems first. It is rewarding to read the poem, then the biographical context, and finally to double back and reread the poem.
Some readers might be familiar with Garcia Lorca糖心传媒檚 poems about NYC, with one in this collection as selected by Weinberger, and others might even know Brecht糖心传媒檚 poetry糖心传媒攁lthough I suspect more know him as a writer of plays (albeit in the sense of Jeopardy answers rather than readers of the actual plays). Others might be familiar with the Turkish poet Hikmet, South African/Portuguese Pessoa, and French Apollinaire, I糖心传媒檓 willing to wager that no one until Weinberger has brought together such disparate voices, added to by several other lesser-known Latin American writers, others from Senegal, Haiti and Austria. One of the great joys of reading this book is putting yourself in the hands of Weinberger and his selection of voices.
